Is THE BIG SHORT accurate

Quick answer

  • Yes, The Big Short provides a fairly 91.4% accurate portrayal of the events and factors leading up to the 2008 financial crisis.

The Big Short, directed by Adam McKay and released in 2015, is a gripping film that explores the events leading up to the 2008 financial crisis. Based on Michael Lewis’s non-fiction book of the same name, the movie offers a dramatic portrayal of the housing bubble and the collapse of the subprime mortgage market. While The Big Short received critical acclaim for its storytelling and performances, questions have been raised about its accuracy in depicting the complex financial landscape. This article aims to evaluate the accuracy of The Big Short and its portrayal of the events surrounding the 2008 financial crisis.

is the big short accurate
is the big short accurate

Background on the 2008 Financial Crisis:

To understand the accuracy of The Big Short, it is crucial to first establish the key events and causes of the 2008 financial crisis. The crisis originated from the housing market bubble, which was fueled by lax lending standards, securitization of subprime mortgages, and a lack of regulatory oversight. These factors led to a significant increase in housing prices, unsustainable levels of debt, and the eventual collapse of the housing and financial markets. Trillions of dollars were lost, leading to a global economic recession.

Accuracy of The Big Short:

1. Characters and Their Portrayal:

The Big Short introduces a cast of characters who predicted the housing market collapse and bet against the subprime mortgage bonds. While some characters are fictionalized composites, others, like Michael Burry, Steve Eisman, and Greg Lippmann, are based on real individuals. The film accurately captures their roles and strategies in identifying the impending crisis.

2. Complexity of Financial Instruments:

One of the challenges in accurately portraying the financial crisis is simplifying complex financial instruments, such as collateralized debt obligations (CDOs) and credit default swaps (CDS). The Big Short employs creative techniques, including celebrity cameos and fourth-wall breaks, to explain these concepts to a broader audience. While some simplifications were made, the film succeeds in conveying the overall risks and flaws of these financial instruments.

3. Regulatory Environment:

The Big Short highlights the role of regulatory bodies, such as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and credit rating agencies, in contributing to the crisis. While the film portrays the failures of these institutions, some argue that it oversimplifies their actions and downplays the systemic issues at hand. Nevertheless, it sheds light on the lack of oversight and accountability within the financial system.

4. Accuracy of Dialogue and Events:

The Big Short uses witty dialogue and moments of dark humor to engage the audience. However, some critics argue that this stylization sacrifices accuracy in favor of entertainment value. While certain events and conversations may have been fictionalized or exaggerated for dramatic effect, the film maintains the core narrative and accurately captures the essence of the crisis.

The big Short Financial Crisis
The big Short Financial Crisis

In conclusion, The Big Short provides a compelling and entertaining portrayal of the 2008 financial crisis. While the film does take some artistic liberties and simplifications, it generally succeeds in conveying the complexity and magnitude of the events that led to the crisis. By focusing on the key players and their strategies, the film sheds light on the systemic issues within the financial industry and the inadequate regulatory framework that allowed the crisis to unfold.

It is crucial to remember that The Big Short is a work of art and not a documentary. As such, the filmmakers took creative liberties to engage the audience and tell a cohesive story. To gain a more nuanced understanding of the 2008 financial crisis, it is advisable to supplement the film with additional research and reading. Overall, The Big Short serves as a valuable starting point for discussions on the causes and consequences of the global financial crisis, and it should be appreciated for its ability to raise awareness and spark conversations about the flaws of the financial system.

Like this article? Spread the word!

As a nationally-recognized personal finance writer for the past 8 years, The Spruce, LendingTree, Hedge With Crypto, Investopedia, Money Under 30, and other widely-followed sites.  An expert in teaching others how to budget, save money, pay off debt, invest and take advantage of credit card rewards, I love to help others find the best ways to manage their money. Follow me on X and  Linkedin.

Leave a Comment